Veritasluxa Companion

Things worth knowing, explained plainly

Toronto, Canada

Your Money Which household papers to keep, and which to let go
The Table

Hot spots, rack positions and the lie your oven tells about temperature

Domestic ovens run hotter or cooler than they claim, heat unevenly and behave differently on every shelf, and an afternoon spent learning yours improves everything you bake or roast in it.

A recipe that produced perfect biscuits in one kitchen burns them at the back and leaves them pale at the front in another. The cook blames the recipe, or themselves. The likelier culprit is the large metal box neither of them has ever checked.

An oven is the least examined tool in most kitchens. It is trusted to be at whatever temperature the dial says, evenly, from the moment a light goes off. Very few domestic ovens manage all three. The good news is that an oven's quirks are consistent, and once you know them you can cook around them without thinking.

The dial is a request, and the beep is optimistic

An oven holds its temperature by switching the heat on and off. It heats past the target, shuts off, drifts below, and fires again, so the air inside swings above and below the set point throughout cooking. On top of that swing, the thermostat itself can be out, and it is not unusual for an oven to sit noticeably hotter or cooler than its setting for its whole life.

A simple oven thermometer that hangs from or stands on a shelf tells you the truth for very little money. Place it in the centre of the middle shelf, set the oven to a moderate temperature, and read it through the door glass several times over half an hour once the oven claims to be ready. The average is what matters. If it runs consistently high or low, simply adjust the dial by that amount from then on. Some ovens allow the offset to be corrected in their settings, and the manual will say how.

The beep or light generally means the air near the sensor has reached temperature. The walls, floor and shelves are still catching up, and they hold most of the oven's heat. Open the door at that point and the hot air spills out, leaving little in reserve to recover with.

Giving the oven another ten to fifteen minutes after it signals lets the metal soak up heat. This matters most for anything that depends on a strong early burst: bread, pastry, pizza, roast potatoes. For the same reason, look through the glass when you can. Each time the door opens the temperature drops sharply, and a cake in its first twenty minutes is poorly placed to cope with that.

Map the hot spots with a tray of bread

Almost every oven is hotter in some places than others, usually towards the back or on the side nearest the heat source. You can see the pattern in fifteen minutes.

  1. Heat the oven to about 180°C (350°F) with a shelf in the middle.
  2. Cover a large baking tray edge to edge with slices of cheap white bread.
  3. Bake until the slices are clearly toasted, checking after about eight minutes.
  4. Take the tray out and look at it from above, noting which way round it was. The darkest slices mark the hot zones.
  5. Take a photograph, and repeat on another shelf or with the fan on if you use those often.

The practical response is rotation. Turn trays front to back about halfway through, and if two trays are in at once, swap their shelves at the same time. Wait until baked goods have set before doing it, roughly two thirds of the way through for cakes.

What each shelf position is for

Top thirdHottest air and reflected heat from the roof: browning tops, gratins, finishing a pale dish
MiddleThe most even heat: cakes, biscuits, most single-tray baking and roasting
Bottom thirdStrong heat from below: crisping pastry bases and pizza, tall roasts that would otherwise sit too close to the roof
Oven floorNot a shelf. Blocking it with trays or foil can disrupt airflow and damage some ovens; check the manual
A general guide for a conventional oven without the fan

Fan, no fan, and the grill

A fan oven, also called convection, blows hot air around the cavity. Moving air transfers heat more efficiently and carries moisture off the surface of food, so things cook faster and brown and crisp more readily. The usual adjustment when a recipe was written for a conventional oven is to lower the temperature by around 15 to 20°C (about 25°F) and start checking a little earlier. Many recipes state which they mean. If one does not, the cooking times will often give it away.

  • Use the fan for roast vegetables and meat, anything you want crisp, and baking on more than one shelf at a time.
  • Consider turning it off for delicate cakes, custards and souffles, which can set on the outside too quickly, dome or crack in a strong draught.
  • The grill, or broiler, is a different tool: intense direct heat from above. It browns surfaces in minutes and cooks little beneath them, so stay next to it.
  • Bottom heat alone, where an oven offers it, is useful for finishing a tart or pie whose base is underdone.

Tins, trays and upkeep

The tray or tin is part of the oven. Dark metal absorbs heat and browns bases faster. Pale, shiny metal reflects it and bakes more gently. Glass and ceramic heat slowly and hold heat long after they come out, so food in them carries on cooking on the counter. If a recipe was developed in one and you use another, expect to adjust the time by a few minutes.

Air has to circulate. Leave a gap of a few centimetres between trays and the oven walls, and avoid lining whole shelves with foil. A heavy baking stone or steel left on a lower shelf acts as a heat store and steadies the swings, which helps bread and pizza in particular, though the oven then needs considerably longer to preheat.

Check the door seal now and then. A gasket that is torn, flattened or crusted with grease leaks heat, and the side nearest the leak will bake differently. Wipe spills once the oven is cool, before they carbonise and smoke at the next high-heat roast. And when something comes out unexpectedly well or badly, make a note of the shelf, the setting and the time on the recipe itself. After a few months those scribbles amount to an instruction manual for your oven that no manufacturer could have written.

  • oven
  • baking
  • roasting
  • kitchen equipment