Veritasluxa Companion

Things worth knowing, explained plainly

Toronto, Canada

Your Money Which household papers to keep, and which to let go
The Table

The last two minutes decide your pasta: finish it in the sauce

Pasta and sauce become one dish only when they finish cooking together, with a ladle of starchy water to bind them, and that step takes two minutes most home cooks skip.

The usual way to serve pasta at home is to drain it thoroughly, pile it into bowls and spoon sauce over the top. Each person then stirs their own. What they get is noodles that are slippery and plain on the inside of the heap, a sauce that slides off, and a thin reddish liquid collecting at the bottom of the bowl.

A plate of pasta in a decent restaurant is different in one specific way: the sauce coats every piece and stays there. That is not a better sauce or a better pasta. It is a different last step. The pasta is pulled from the water early and finishes cooking in the sauce, with some of its cooking water added, and those two minutes do most of the work.

Season the water, because it is the only chance you get

Dried pasta is flour and water. It has no salt in it, and it absorbs water as it cooks. If that water is salted, the pasta is seasoned all the way through. If it is not, no sauce will fully make up for it, and you end up over-salting the sauce to compensate for bland noodles.

A widely used rule of thumb is around 10 grams of salt per litre of water, which is a heaped teaspoon or so of fine salt, and the water should taste pleasantly seasoned, like a well-made soup. The old line about making it as salty as the sea overshoots badly. Go lighter if the sauce contains salty things such as anchovies, cured pork, olives or a lot of hard cheese, since some of that water is going into the pan.

You do not need a cauldron. A moderate amount of water, enough for the pasta to move freely, comes to the boil faster and ends up starchier, which helps later. Stir during the first minute or two, when the surfaces are sticky and pieces are most likely to weld together. Oil in the water does not prevent sticking. It floats on top, and what little clings to the pasta makes it harder for sauce to grip.

What the cloudy water is for

As pasta cooks it sheds starch, and the water turns cloudy. That starch is a mild thickener and, more usefully, it helps fat and water hold together. A sauce is mostly those two things trying to separate. A splash of starchy water, with heat and movement, persuades them into a single glossy coating that sticks to the pasta.

So before draining, scoop out a mugful. Better still, do not drain at all: lift long pasta out with tongs and short shapes with a slotted spoon or a small sieve, straight into the sauce. Enough water comes along on its own, and the rest stays in the pot if you need more. Never rinse pasta that is going into a hot sauce. Rinsing washes off the surface starch that makes the sauce cling.

The finish, step by step

  1. Have the sauce warm in a pan wide enough to hold all the pasta. A frying pan or a wide saute pan is better than the pot the sauce was made in.
  2. Start tasting the pasta two to three minutes before the time on the packet. You want it flexible, with a firm, slightly chalky core.
  3. Transfer it to the sauce along with a small ladle of cooking water.
  4. Cook over a lively heat, tossing or stirring constantly, for a minute or two. The liquid will reduce and turn from watery to creamy.
  5. Add more water a splash at a time if it tightens before the pasta is done. Stop when the sauce coats the pasta and only a little loose liquid remains.
  6. Take the pan off the heat, then add cheese, butter or raw olive oil and toss once more.

Going off the heat before the cheese matters. Grated hard cheese dropped into a pan that is still boiling clumps into rubbery strings. Stirred into pasta that has stopped bubbling, with a little water to loosen it, it melts into the sauce.

Aim for a sauce that looks slightly too loose in the pan. Pasta keeps absorbing liquid on the way to the table, and what looked perfect on the stove will be stodgy by the third forkful.

Matching shape to sauce

Shapes are not interchangeable decoration. The useful question is where the sauce is going to end up: coating a strand, sitting in a hollow, or caught on a ridge.

Long thin strands such as spaghetti and linguineSmooth, oil-based or light tomato sauces, and seafood
Long ribbons such as tagliatelle and pappardelleRich, slow-cooked meat sauces and creamy sauces
Tubes and ridged shapes such as penne and rigatoniChunky vegetable or meat sauces, and baked dishes
Twists and shells such as fusilli and conchigliePesto and sauces with small pieces that lodge in the folds
Very small shapesSoups and broths
A practical pairing guide

Common faults and what causes them

  • A watery pool in the bowl: the pasta was added wet to a sauce and never cooked together with it. Give it another minute over the heat.
  • Dry, sticky pasta: too little liquid at the finish. Add cooking water, a splash at a time, until it loosens.
  • Greasy, separated sauce: plenty of fat and nothing binding it. Starchy water and vigorous tossing fix this.
  • Soft, swollen pasta: it was cooked to the packet time and then cooked again in the sauce. Pull it earlier.
  • A solid lump in the colander: it sat drained while the sauce was finished. The sauce should be waiting for the pasta, never the other way round.

That last point is really one of timing. Start the sauce before the water goes on for anything that takes longer than the pasta does. For quick sauces built on garlic and oil or butter and cheese, the pasta's cooking time is the sauce's cooking time, and the pan should be ready and warm when the pasta is two minutes from done.

  • pasta
  • sauces
  • weeknight cooking
  • technique