Why a ten-mile hill day is never just ten miles of walking
Distance is the least useful number on a route description. Height gain, ground, stops and the slowest person decide when you get back.
Most late finishes start with a sentence like this: it is only eight miles, we will be back by three. Eight miles on a canal towpath is under three hours. Eight miles over two summits, with a boggy mile, a boulder field and a long lunch, can be seven. Nobody walked slowly. The estimate was simply for a different walk.
Start with a rule, then correct it
The traditional starting point is a simple formula: allow an hour for every three miles on the map, and add half an hour for every thousand feet of climbing. In metric, that is roughly five kilometers an hour plus ten minutes for every hundred meters of ascent. It was devised for fit walkers on reasonable ground with no stops, which is why it flatters almost everyone.
Treat the result as the fastest the day could plausibly go, and then add what the formula leaves out. The corrections are where the accuracy is.
| Rough ground | Bog, heather, tussocks, boulders and pathless slopes can halve your speed. |
|---|---|
| Steep descent | Gentle downhill is quick. Steep or loose downhill is as slow as going up. |
| Stops | Food, photos, layers on and off, map checks. Often ten to fifteen minutes in every hour. |
| Load | A camping pack slows the climbs and the descents. |
| Group size | Every stile, gate and pause is multiplied by the number of people. |
| Conditions | Headwind, heat, snow, wet rock and poor visibility all cost time. |
A workable habit for a mixed group on ordinary hill paths is to take the formula's answer and add between a quarter and a half again. On rough or pathless ground, or with young children, add more. If that sounds pessimistic, compare it with your last three walks.
Measure your own pace
Rules of thumb describe an average person who does not exist. Your own numbers are better and easy to collect. For the next few outings, note the time you set off, the time at each obvious point such as a summit or a junction, and the time you finish, including stops. A phone or watch that records the track will do this for you, but a pencil on the edge of the map works as well.
After a handful of walks you will know two things that matter far more than any formula: your real all-in speed for a day on the hill, breaks included, and how much that drops in the last third when legs are tired. Most people find their overall figure is closer to two miles an hour than three. That is not slow. It is what a day out actually looks like.
The slowest person sets the time
A group moves at the pace of its slowest member on the slowest type of ground for them. One person who is cautious on steep descents, or a child who walks well for two hours and then stops, defines the day. Plan around them from the start rather than hoping they will keep up, and put them near the front, where they set the pace instead of chasing it.
- Ask about recent walks, not general fitness. A strong runner may be slow on rocky paths.
- Count regrouping time. Fast walkers who wait at the top have rested; the person who arrives last has not, and needs a few minutes before you move again.
- Agree in advance that the route can be shortened, and where.
Work backward from dark
The estimate only matters in relation to daylight. Look up sunset for the place and date, remembering that useful light goes earlier in deep valleys, in forest and under heavy cloud. Then plan to be off the difficult ground with a clear margin, and count backward.
- Take the time you want to be back at the start, at least an hour before sunset.
- Subtract your corrected estimate for the whole route. That is the latest sensible start.
- Mark the halfway point in time, not distance. On an out-and-back with the climb first, the return is usually quicker; on a round with a late climb, it is not.
- Set a turnaround time: the moment at which you head down from wherever you are, summit or no summit.
- Note the escape routes, the places where a shorter way back to a road or valley leaves the main route, and the latest point at which each can be used.
Write the key times on the map or in your phone notes. A turnaround time that exists only as a vague intention gets renegotiated at exactly the moment when judgment is worst, with the top in sight and everybody keen.
Check the estimate while you walk
The first hour tells you whether the plan is real. If you expected to reach the first col at ten and it is twenty to eleven, you are running a third slow, and that proportion will usually hold or get worse through the day. Do the arithmetic there and then: apply the same slip to the remaining time and see where it puts the finish.
If the answer is after dark, the decision is easy at eleven in the morning and hard at four in the afternoon. Shorten the route at the next escape point, drop the second summit, or turn the walk into an out-and-back. A torch in the pack is a sensible backup, but it is a way of coping with a mistake, not a reason to make one. The walkers who rarely get caught out are not faster than anyone else. They simply find out early that they are behind.